Whitening Cream vs Brightening Products: What Is the Difference and Why Is Safety Testing Mandatory in Indonesia?

Growing consumer interest in skin-brightening products has intensified competition in the cosmetics industry. Manufacturers and beauty brands are continuously striving to increase their product value through formula innovation, active ingredient selection, technology, and marketing strategies.

One commonly used approach is the choice of product terminology and claims, such as whitening cream and brightening. Although both terms are associated with improving skin appearance, cosmetic claims must comply with the regulations established by Indonesia’s National Agency of Drug and Food Control (BPOM).

Table of Content:

The Difference Between Whitening Cream and Brightening According to BPOM

In marketing contexts, whitening cream is generally associated with making the skin appear whiter, whereas brightening refers to improving the skin’s appearance by making it look brighter, fresher, less dull, and more even-toned. Under BPOM Regulation No. 3 of 2022 concerning Technical Requirements for Cosmetic Claims, cosmetic claims must be objective, non-misleading, and consistent with the actual benefits of the product.

BPOM provides examples of permitted claims, such as brightening the skin and reducing the appearance of dark spots. In contrast, claims such as whitening the face and completely eliminating dark spots are considered unacceptable. Therefore, this does not mean that every use of the term whitening cream is automatically illegal or that brightening claims are always permitted.

Claims are assessed based on their overall meaning and context, particularly for products marketed as a whitening cream. The term brightening is generally more appropriate for describing cosmetic benefits related to improving the skin’s appearance rather than permanently changing its natural skin tone.

Active Ingredients for Brightening Products

Developing skin-brightening products requires careful consideration of permitted active ingredients, concentrations, safety, and formulation objectives. Some ingredients that may be used in accordance with applicable regulations include:

  1. Tranexamic Acid: Helps reduce the appearance of hyperpigmentation and dark spots.
  2. Vitamin C: Acts as an antioxidant and helps improve the appearance of dark spots and dull skin.
  3. Niacinamide: Helps reduce melanosome transfer, promoting a more even skin tone while supporting the skin barrier.
  4. Alpha Arbutin: Helps inhibit tyrosinase activity, an enzyme involved in melanin production.
  5. Glycolic Acid: Helps remove dead skin cells through exfoliation, leaving the skin looking smoother and brighter.
  6. Licorice Extract: Contains compounds that help reduce the appearance of pigmentation and provide antioxidant benefits.

Ingredients Prohibited or Restricted in Cosmetics

Not all skin-brightening ingredients are permitted for use in cosmetic products. Mercury is prohibited due to its potential health risks. Hydroquinone is not permitted as a skin-lightening ingredient for facial cosmetics.

Retinoic acid and corticosteroids, such as dexamethasone, are also not permitted as active ingredients in conventional cosmetic formulations. Their use must comply with applicable pharmaceutical requirements and regulations.

The Importance of Formulation Quality Testing

Choosing the term brightening is not merely a marketing strategy; it must also be supported by safe, high-quality formulations. Manufacturers must ensure that active ingredient concentrations meet product specifications, formulation stability is maintained, and product claims are supported by reliable evidence. Therefore, laboratory testing plays an essential role in cosmetic product development.

Conduct your Cosmetic Safety and Hazardous Substance Detection Testing with IML Testing and Research

If you are developing a skin-brightening product, ensure that your formulation quality and active ingredient concentrations are tested at IML Testing Research. Through appropriate laboratory testing, manufacturers can maintain product quality consistency, support ingredient verification, and strengthen consumer confidence in the products they bring to market.

Consult Your Whitening Cream Safety Testing Now!

Author: Delfia
Editor: Lina

References

Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Republik Indonesia. (2022). Peraturan Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Nomor 3 Tahun 2022 tentang Persyaratan Teknis Klaim Kosmetika [Regulation of the National Agency of Drug and Food Control No. 3 of 2022 concerning Technical Requirements for Cosmetic Claims]. https://jdih.pom.go.id/

Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Republik Indonesia. (2025). Peraturan Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Nomor 25 Tahun 2025 tentang Persyaratan Teknis Bahan Kosmetik [Regulation of the National Agency of Drug and Food Control No. 25 of 2025 concerning Technical Requirements for Cosmetic Ingredients]. https://jdih.pom.go.id/

Share your love

Hubungi kami untuk informasi yang Anda perlukan.

Silakan konsultasikan kebutuhan pengujian produk Anda dengan tim ahli kami secara gratis.

Formulir Kontak